Employer · plans filed under one EIN
Utica Mutual Insurance Company
New Hartford, NY · Finance and insurance
Form 5500 information is as filed by the plan administrator with the Department of Labor and may be amended. Figures reflect the plan year shown, not current balances.
2 retirement plans with 100 or more participants file Form 5500 under Utica Mutual Insurance Company's employer identification number (New Hartford, New York). Their latest filings total 3,268 participant records and $723M in net assets.
The largest is Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employee Profit Sharing and Investment Plan, a 401(k) plan with 1,994 participants. A person can be counted in more than one plan, so the participant total is a count of records rather than of people.
Employer contributions across the plans were $9.1M and participant contributions $12.5M in the latest plan years; benefits paid were $51.3M. Schedule C compensation reported to service provider organisations totalled $753K.
Combined net assets moved from $315M in 2009 to $723M in 2024 (up 130%). Plan mergers and spin-offs show up here as steps in the series.
Plans
| Plan | Kind | Plan year | Participants | Net assets | Per participant | Employer / active | Sch. C compensation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employee Profit Sharing and Investment Plan | 401(k) plan | 2024 | 1,994 | $348M | $174,408 | $6,514 | $332K |
| Retirement Income Plan of Utica Mutual Insurance Company | defined benefit pension plan | 2024 | 1,274 | $375M | $294,381 | $0 | $421K |
| US median, plan year 2024: DC plans $53,102 per participant, $2,175 employer contribution per active participant; DB plans $86,221 and $10,244. | |||||||
Trend by plan year
| Plan year | Plans | Participant records | Net assets | Employer contributions | Participant contributions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 2 | 3,268 | $723M | $9.1M | $12.5M |
| 2023 | 2 | 3,297 | $688M | $8.4M | $11.7M |
| 2022 | 2 | 3,240 | $608M | $6.5M | $10.6M |
| 2021 | 2 | 3,334 | $782M | $5.7M | $9.7M |
| 2020 | 2 | 3,646 | $730M | $5.8M | $8.7M |
| 2019 | 2 | 3,675 | $629M | $5.0M | $8.0M |
| 2018 | 2 | 3,793 | $536M | $14.8M | $7.4M |
| 2017 | 2 | 3,711 | $573M | $11.6M | $6.9M |
| 2016 | 2 | 3,671 | $497M | $10.5M | $6.4M |
| 2015 | 2 | 4,106 | $475M | $2.8M | $6.1M |
| 2014 | 2 | 4,009 | $495M | $3.1M | $6.0M |
| 2013 | 2 | 4,049 | $457M | $1.4M | $6.4M |
| 2012 | 2 | 4,116 | $411M | $4.9M | $6.0M |
| 2011 | 2 | 4,151 | $367M | $5.0M | $5.8M |
| 2010 | 2 | 4,105 | $353M | $8.9M | $5.5M |
| 2009 | 2 | 3,955 | $315M | $10.6M | $5.4M |
History of the plans listed above, in the years each filed the full Form 5500 with 100 or more participants. Plans that have since terminated are not included.
Service providers
| Organisation | Services reported | Plans | Compensation reported |
|---|---|---|---|
| John Hancock | Claims processing; Recordkeeping and information management; Investment management; Participant communication | 1 | $193,431 |
| CAPTRUST | Consulting (general); Investment advisory (plan) | 2 | $151,500 |
| Vanguard Advisers Inc. | Investment advisory (participants) | 1 | $141,731 |
| The Vanguard Group, Inc. | Recordkeeping and information management; Consulting (general); Custodial (securities); Participant loan processing | 1 | $132,320 |
| Willis Towers Watson US LLC | Actuarial; Consulting (pension) | 1 | $111,343 |
| Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP | Consulting (general); Legal | 2 | $22,640 |
Organisations paid $5,000 or more by any of these plans, from Schedule C. Individuals are not shown.
Questions and answers
How many retirement plans does Utica Mutual Insurance Company have?
2 plans with 100 or more participants filed Form 5500 under its employer identification number for the latest plan years: Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employee Profit Sharing and Investment Plan and Retirement Income Plan of Utica Mutual Insurance Company. Smaller plans and plans filed under a subsidiary's number are not grouped here.
How much does Utica Mutual Insurance Company contribute to its plans?
$9,054,044 in employer contributions across these plans in their latest plan years, about $5,652 per active participant record. Form 5500 reports totals and not the match or accrual formula.
Who provides services to these plans?
Schedule C filings name John Hancock, CAPTRUST, Vanguard Advisers Inc. and The Vanguard Group, Inc. and others. Only organisations paid $5,000 or more by a plan are listed on Schedule C.
Where does this come from?
Form 5500 annual reports filed with the Department of Labor's EFAST2 system, from the EBSA research files, with filings received through 24 Aug 2026. Figures are as filed and may be amended.
Provenance
Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Employee Benefits Security Administration, Form 5500 research files, public domain, with filings received through 24 Aug 2026. Plans are grouped by the sponsor's employer identification number exactly as filed; a company that files under several EINs appears as several employers. See the methodology and corrections.